After Rep. Gerry Connolly said he would be “stepping back” as the lead Democrat on the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform because his cancer returned, Democrats on the committee privately began debating who could replace him.
But House Democratic leadership made clear Tuesday that there is “no vacancy” on Oversight and therefore no race to replace Connolly.
“We are conducting ourselves in a way that he and the committee desire and that is for leadership to step up and help run meetings as well,” Caucus Chair Pete Aguilar said.
The messaging from leadership has stoked a wave of confusion among House Democrats about the committee’s future as well as a shadow race to take the party’s top spot on the panel that is already replicating the tense generational dynamics of last year’s race.
Rep. Stephen Lynch will be temporarily taking over his duties on the committee, two people familiar told NOTUS. Lynch already has taken on leadership responsibilities, speaking on behalf of the panel at House Democrats’ weekly meeting Tuesday morning.
“This week, I spoke with Mr. Connolly following his announcement that he will be stepping back from the day-to-day leadership of Oversight Committee Democrats due to his health,” Lynch told NOTUS in a statement after this story published. “I am honored that he asked me to assume interim responsibilities and expressed his support for me to seek the Ranking Member position on a full-time basis — should a vacancy occur.”
The 70-year-old Lynch isn’t often in the national spotlight and has sided with Republicans on controversial policies, voting against the Affordable Care Act in 2010 and supporting the Laken Riley Act in January.
His interest in the role — alongside his increased current responsibilities — sets up the potential for a thematic repeat of Connolly’s 2024 ranking member race against progressive star Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.
The younger, more diverse Democrats on the committee are again privately grumbling about the committee’s leadership, set on seeing a candidate in the top job who more closely reflects their interests.
Democrats now see the ranking member spot on the committee as a public-facing perch to take on the Trump administration in a bombastic, viral way to reach voters. Democrats view this job as especially important during this administration, where they’ve been attempting to fight back against Elon Musk’s government cuts through DOGE. And it’s typically a committee that takes younger progressive, diverse members in its ranks.
“I think it’s certainly an opportunity for a new generation of leadership to step in, but we’ll see,” Rep. Emily Randall, who’s on the committee and in her first year in Congress, said Tuesday morning.
Progressives on the committee have long been enthusiastic about Ocasio-Cortez’s candidacy, hoping her high profile and dogged questioning style can elevate Democratic messaging. But she has not publicly said she is interested in the job, and her office did not respond to a request for comment.
“If she ran again, I would certainly support her,” Randall said of Ocasio-Cortez.
For now, multiple Democrats on the committee told NOTUS they are confused about the process and noted a difference between Connolly’s announced intention to step back from Oversight on Monday and leadership saying there is “no vacancy” on Tuesday.
When NOTUS asked Aguilar about whether there would be an election and what the timeline would be, he did not provide any specifics.
The situation now appears similar to when Rep. Carolyn Maloney took over as acting chair of Oversight for Rep. Elijah Cummings in 2019. A key difference, however, is that Maloney was serving as vice chair. Rep. Jasmine Crockett is currently serving as vice ranking member of the committee, and Rep. Eleanor Holmes Norton is the most senior member.
A couple of Democrats privately questioned to NOTUS why Lynch was selected to assume responsibilities for Connolly.
“When I was unanimously elected as the vice ranker, I was ready and willing then to step in on behalf of the caucus, as well as on behalf of the country, to do the job. I am ready and willing still to stand up and push back and do the work of this committee and lead it,” Crockett told NOTUS.
“I fully anticipate that when a vacancy arises that I will submit my name,” she said.
Other House Democrats aren’t ruling out a bid. When asked if she’s interested, DOGE Subcommittee Ranking Member Rep. Melanie Stansbury told NOTUS: “I don’t think anything’s at that point yet.”
Rep. Ro Khanna, who is also on the committee, said in a statement that Connolly “has stepped back, not stepped aside.”
“I’m praying for him and his family. I’m focused on that right now and our committee’s work,” he said.
And other Democrats on the committee privately pointed to Reps. Robert Garcia and Maxwell Frost as members who could be in the mix.
—
Daniella Diaz and Riley Rogerson are reporters at NOTUS.