In the photo, she stares up and away. Not at the masked men seated in front of her, or behind her, or packed tight to her right, or reflected in the window glass. Not at their shoulder patches, which say “Life - Liberty - Victory.” They’re hidden behind hats and sunglasses and stretchy white masks, clonelike in their uniforms and their numbers. The train hurtles on.
Her face is unguarded. She doesn’t hide.
It was Independence Day, America’s 250th birthday. Before the photo, the men marched in the nation’s capital and rallied at Union Station. Some carried upside-down American flags, a symbol of distress.
After the photo, the woman went to her mother’s house. She didn’t say anything about the masked men. Instead, she told her mom she was going to church and the store, and she’d come right back. She did not come back.
Trending
That quick, her photo was everywhere. And she was gone.
* * *
The image was destined for history books. It defined America. It deserved a Pulitzer Prize.
Her face flashed on CNN, ABC, MS NOW, as far as the Times of India and Australia’s national newspaper.
Reuters posted the photo on Instagram at 1:10 p.m. ET on July 4, and over the next week, millions of people saw it.
A CNN headline read: “What the viral image of a Black woman surrounded by white nationalists on the DC metro says about America today.” The NAACP captioned it: “No Fear. No Retreat. Still Here.” She was called a “contemporary Rosa Parks” and “a beautiful, powerful woman.”
Jamie Lee Curtis wrote on Instagram: “This photograph has changed us all.” Flavor Flav responded: “This is the most historically important photo for today’s times.”
It joined the iconic images of this fractured decade: A bleeding Trump with his fist in the air. Torches in Charlottesville. Charlie Kirk mid-collapse. QAnon Shaman. Nothing reads the same way to everyone anymore. Not even the flag.
The look on the woman’s face was quiet resistance or forced stoicism or a survival mechanism or a haunting echo.
“Once again, a Black woman was captured in a moment where she must confront the worst of America with composure and become the mirror that shows the distance between who we are and who we say we are — or who we want to be — as a country,” wrote Errin Haines, editor-at-large at The 19th.
“I do not need to know who she is to know who she is.”
She was Ruby Bridges now. She was Anne Moody at the lunch counter. She was the Little Rock Nine.
“It was us,” wrote Roy S. Johnson for AL.com. “It showed that we’re all on this crowded train — some of us minding our own business; some of us filled with hate, fear and insecurity. All of us riding somewhere, just trying to reach our stop, to arrive where we want to be. All riding together.”
The Washington Post could not locate her, but published her name and age and paraphrased a family member saying she struggled with mental illnesses.
Her name had already bubbled up online, which led to internet searches, which led to a morass of judgment and assumption. A white nationalist posted an AI-generated video purporting to show the woman pulling down her pants on the train. The video infected comment feeds across social media.
“Why is this woman being spoken ABOUT,” read a comment on Instagram about the Post’s story, “instead of spoken TO???”
* * *
“Bernita is on Instagram with some men,” one of her brothers told their mom.
Roberta Bowlding was stunned. What was he talking about? She searched online. That’s when she saw it.
“This is embarrassing,” she thought.
She wondered if her daughter had agreed to be photographed. Roberta, 65, worried those scary-looking men might find out where she lived and come hurt them.
She kept staring at Bernita’s now-viral expression and imagined she might have been thinking, “Who are all these people?”
She wished her daughter would come home.
Bernita’s older brother, Joseph Bowlding, thought she looked scared. “That’s my sister,” he said. “I know her face.”
He saw the Bernita who, as a kid, danced to Michael Jackson. Who played kickball and was good at math and had friends and loved church and wanted to be a nurse.
Bernita, 33, was a different person now, and they needed to find her. They were upset that the photo existed. Everyone in Roberta’s building seemed to know about her daughter’s viral moment. Roberta didn’t like that.
People online compared his sister to Rosa Parks but Joseph shook his head. Rosa Parks had agency. She chose to make a stand. His sister was just riding the Orange Line.
“They say that ‘We love you, we got you,’ but the reality is that this woman is homeless,” he said. “Are they willing to sacrifice and say, ‘Let’s help her get a place?’ Are they willing to do that?”
“The more views they get, they’re getting money.”
A younger brother, Paul Bowlding, wrote on his Instagram story: “If you see my sister call me asap 😔🥺just worried she lost her phone haven’t seen her in a while.”
“They don’t understand her. They don’t know how our family feels,” Joseph said. “It was important to hear the true side of who she really is, instead of just like a fantasy fairytale.”
None of them could reach Bernita. Roberta thought she had lost her phone again and needed help. She usually stays at her mom’s house for a few days, leaves for two or three days, then comes back. Her last words before leaving this time were “I love you.” Joseph let his mind go to dark places. Was she kidnapped? Did one of the masked men hurt her?
“If she’s not taking the medicine,” her mom said, “she’s not herself.”
How could so many people see the same photo of the same woman, and not see Bernita at all?
At 8:59 p.m. on July 8 — three days after they last saw her — the family reported Bernita Bowlding missing to Prince George’s County Police. She had been wearing gray pants and a green top, Roberta told the police.
She became case number 26-0036334.
* * *
A few hours after Roswell Encina stepped off the train, he saw the photo.
The woman was alone, just like he had been, and surrounded. There had been a photographer on his train, too. Maybe his photo would hit the internet next.
He had been listening to “Confessions II,” Madonna’s new album, but turned it off when the men arrived. He didn’t know who they were, but they made him nervous.
“Oh my goodness!” Encina texted his friends. “Here I am in a gingham blue shirt, and red bandana, and blue boat shoes.”
He told his friends he was manspreading so the scary men wouldn’t sit next to him.
“God help me,” he typed.
His only comfort was the Getty photojournalist, whose presence ensured that whatever happened wouldn’t happen in secret. Encina, 56, is the CEO and president of the United States Capitol Historical Society, a nonpartisan nonprofit chartered by Congress “to foster and increase an informed patriotism.”
Later, when he did see the photo of himself on the train, he thought, “I’m a gay Filipino American. And I look like it.”
On July 5, at 9:17 a.m., he posted it to his public Instagram account of more than 3,000 followers, along with a carefully worded reflection on democracy:
“The day after Independence Day feels like the right time to remember that patriotism isn’t about intimidation or fear. It is about having the courage to keep widening the circle of liberty, dignity, and opportunity.”
The photo of Encina was taken three minutes before the more famous one of Bernita. But the narrative about the photo of Encina was one he wrote himself. When he posted it, he thought about the woman in the other photo. He knew nothing about her, but he suspected he had a certain agency that she might not.
The cable outlets and commentators would be calling. He could testify that the fear on his face was real.
* * *
“Let’s talk about that photo,” Kevin DeAnna, a prominent white nationalist and host of the far-right “Identity Politics” podcast, said days later to Thomas Rousseau.
Rousseau had led hundreds of Patriot Front members through the nation’s capitol as they chanted “Reclaim America,” flexed their biceps and waved. He gave a speech about how those with “Anglo-Saxon blood” are the true Americans and called just about everyone else an enemy. The group posted a video in its encrypted chatroom, which had more than 14,000 subscribers.
“It really goes to show how much people on different sides of the political spectrum live in different worlds,” Rousseau said on the podcast. “People on our side can look at that photo and say, ‘So what? You know, nothing happened to her.’”
The Black woman on the Metro “was not accosted,” Rousseau noted. He said he tells his members to give commuters space. “She has a whole row to herself,” he said. “She’s fine.”
Rousseau could not be reached by NOTUS, but on the podcast, he chalked up the commentary to “the liberal sort of, you know, spin on the news.” The virality of the photo had been good for him, he said: Celebrities, politicians and journalists were talking about Patriot Front.
“The demonstration,” he said, “had an impact.”
* * *
Cheney Orr, the photographer, has thought about what it means to be vulnerable in front of a camera. His first long-term photo essay, published in The New York Times, documented his father’s experience with early-onset Alzheimer’s. He was 21 when his dad was diagnosed, and his intimate photos show how the disease stripped his father’s autonomy over the years.
In one photo, his father relies on a caretaker to shave his face. In another, he brushes his teeth in the shower. In other moments, his father appears disoriented and weak.
On July 4, Orr was a freelancer working for Reuters. The agency would not allow him to speak to the press, but they interviewed him about the day. Orr and a friend caught up with Patriot Front right as they boarded the train. It was the busiest Independence Day in Metro’s history, and the car was packed.
“As I photographed members of the group, I noticed the woman you see in this image sitting alone among them,” Orr, 35, told Reuters. “I leaned over seated members of Patriot Front, extended my arm, and composed the frame using my camera’s screen.”
He didn’t realize it was such a strong photo until later.
The group dispersed at the New Carrollton station, and Orr lost track of the woman he photographed. He didn’t get her name. In the caption, she is “a commuter.”
* * *
“Mama,” she called from the porch. “Open the door.”
It was Bernita. Five days after the photo, she was home.
“Where you been?”
Bernita didn’t answer. She seemed tired.
Roberta has asked her daughter if she remembers the train ride. Sometimes she does. She didn’t know the men were white supremacists. She noticed their masks. She said she wasn’t scared. She was not aware enough to be scared. Or defiant. Or resigned. Or anything else people assumed about her.
Roberta was taking her grandchildren to McDonald’s, so Bernita came along. Once everyone got their food, they sat down to eat and the kids lunged into their Happy Meals.
Bernita walked toward the door.
“Nee Nee, come on,” Joseph said.
“Come sit,” her mom said.
“I have to go to the store now,” Bernita said. “We have to go to the store.”
“Just take just five minutes, c’mon,” Roberta said. “Just real quick please.”
Bernita lingered halfway out the door, carrying her Caramel Frappé and fries.
“Can you show her the picture?” Roberta asked.
“It’s about you in the train,” Joseph told her, pointing at the photo.
Bernita paused. She glanced down.
“That’s not me,” she said.
Bernita didn’t know that the photo had gone around the world. She didn’t know she was strong and brave and a symbol of our division and a vessel for our fears. She didn’t know that people who didn’t know her thought they knew her. The icon of America wanted to go now. She needed to pace the parking lot, to sit on the curb, to have some quiet.
Wait. Zoom in. Look again.
“Oh,” Bernita said. “That was me.”
She walked out.
Don’t miss the stories shaping Washington.
Sign in
Log into your free account with your email. Don’t have one?
Check your email for a one-time code.
We sent a 4-digit code to . Enter the pin to confirm your account.
New code will be available in 1:00
Let’s try this again.
We encountered an error with the passcode sent to . Please reenter your email.
You’re on the list! Thank you for reading NOTUS.
Author
